Blog

Fall 2026 Iowa Farmland Auction Results: Why Price Per Acre Misleads

Five northwest Iowa farms sold at auction between September 30 and November 12, 2026. Prices ran from $11,100 to $25,500 an acre. Soil quality barely accounts for that spread. Every farm but one carried a CSR2 between 88 and 96. What actually moved the price was location, how much of the ground can be cropped, and the terms of the sale. The clearest example sits in Cherokee County, where two farms with nearly identical soils sold a day apart at $16,100 and $11,100 an acre. If you are pulling these Iowa farmland auction results to price your own ground, compare price per cropland acre and per CSR2 point, not the headline per-acre number.

Key takeaways

  • Five fall 2026 sales ran from $11,100 to $25,500 an acre, mostly on 88 to 96 CSR2 ground.
  • The headline per-acre number bundles grass, building sites, and CRP. It can mislead badly.
  • Price per cropland acre and per CSR2 point are the fairer comparison tools.
  • Location and cropland share moved price more than a few points of CSR2. In Sioux County, by a wide margin.
  • Four of the five sales advertised an open lease for 2027.

Fall 2026 Iowa farmland auction results: what did northwest Iowa ground sell for?

Here are the results from our fall auctions through November 12. The last two columns are our own arithmetic from the published listing figures: price per acre divided by average CSR2, and total price spread over FSA cropland acres only.

Sale Acres (cropland) CSR2 Price per acre Per CSR2 point Per cropland acre
Sioux County, Tract 1, Sept 30 67 (64.31) 89.4 $25,500 $285 $26,567
Sioux County, Tract 2, Sept 30 80 (77.06) 96.0 $23,000 $240 $23,877
Clay County, Tract 1, Nov 10 40 (39.65) 88.2 $13,600 $154 $13,720
Clay County, Tract 2, Nov 10 52 (52.38) 88.9 $13,000 $146 $12,906
Palo Alto County, Nov 10 40 (35.36) 78.3 $11,300 $144 $12,783
Cherokee County near Cleghorn, Tract 1, Nov 11 85.23 (79.99) 88.6 $16,100 $182 $17,155
Cherokee County near Cleghorn, Tract 2, Nov 11 67.92 (65.56) 89.9 $16,100 $179 $16,680
Cherokee County near Peterson, Nov 12 200 (143.72) 90.8 $11,100 $122 $15,447

The Sioux County sale was co-listed with AgCentric Farm Agency. All sales were subject to seller approval, and the full sale bills, soil maps, and FSA details for each farm are on our previously sold farmland page.

For context, Iowa State’s 2025 survey put the average value of all farmland at $15,983 an acre in Sioux County, $13,665 in Cherokee, $13,112 in Clay, and $12,504 in Palo Alto (ISU county table). Those are county-wide averages across every quality of ground, so a single good farm landing above them is normal. The Cleghorn tracts came in above the Cherokee average. The Peterson farm came in below it.

Why did two Cherokee County farms sell $5,000 apart?

On November 11, 153 acres near Cleghorn brought $16,100 an acre. The next day, 200 acres southwest of Peterson brought $11,100. The Peterson farm actually had the higher CSR2, 90.8 against 88.6 and 89.9. Galva and Primghar soils run through both. On paper they should be close. They are not.

Start with what the buyer was paying for. At Cleghorn, 95% of the acres were cropland. At Peterson it was 72%. The rest was grassland and a rustic building site. That cropland-share gap accounts for about $4,350 of the $5,000 difference.

Put the Peterson farm’s entire $2.22 million on its 143.72 cropland acres, treating the grass and the building site as worth nothing, and the cropland still works out to about $15,450 an acre. That is roughly $650 less than Cleghorn on better-rated soil.

One more clue sits in the FSA records. The Cleghorn farm’s program yields were 166 bushels of corn and 52 of soybeans. Peterson’s were 124 and 36. Program yields are an old, imperfect yardstick. But a gap that wide is likely where the remaining $650 difference comes from. A buyer who knows a 166 from a 124 will bid accordingly, and that shows up in the final number.

Here is the takeaway for an owner. If your neighbor’s farm sold for $16,100, that is not your number. Not until you have matched cropland share, yield history, and location. CSR2 alone will not tell you. If you are holding a screenshot of a neighbor’s sale, the honest answer is that it depends on cropland share and yield history, and we need to see your sale bill.

Why did the lower-CSR2 tract bring more in Sioux County?

On September 30, two tracts sold at Orange City. Tract 1 carried an 89.4 CSR2 and brought $25,500. Tract 2 carried a 96 and brought $23,000. The lower-rated ground brought more, and if you have watched an auction up close, that should not surprise you. It trips up people reading a spreadsheet, though.

Two things worked against the higher-rated tract. Tract 1 sits about two miles from Orange City, and ground that close to town with a strong local buyer base tends to draw extra bidders. More hands in the room means higher bids.

The second thing is the sale format. It was buyer’s choice. The high bidder picked a tract first, and the remaining tract sold afterward. In that format, the first pick sets the high mark, and the tract left behind often brings less, whatever its soils.

We cannot tell you exactly how much each factor contributed. What the sale does show is that once soils are this good, the gap between an 89 and a 96, nearly seven CSR2 points, is worth less than location and sale order. A generalist realtor pricing a Sioux County farm from the county average is going to miss that point entirely.

Did highway frontage help in Clay County?

Not this time. Two tracts north of Spencer sold November 10. Tract 2 sat right on Highway 71 with excellent visibility, and it brought $13,000. Tract 1, a quarter mile west on 300th Street, brought $13,600, even though it needed a new driveway and the sellers credited the buyer $1,500 to put one in.

The details explain it. Tract 2 carried 4.2 acres of CRP under contracts running to 2034 and 2035, which a farming buyer cannot crop for years. Its FSA program yields were also lower, 123 and 37 against 170 and 43. Highway frontage matters to someone who wants to develop. To an operator buying corn ground, it is a ditch and traffic. And 4.2 acres of CRP is 4.2 acres you cannot plant this decade.

Owners often treat highway frontage as a premium. Sometimes it is. Sometimes it is just a faster road next to a farm that has lower yields and restricted acres. The buyer is not paying for the view. They are paying for the cropland.

What does a 78 CSR2 farm bring?

More than people expect. Our 40-acre Palo Alto County farm west of Mallard sold online-only for $11,300 an acre. 35.36 cropland acres averaging 78.3 CSR2 on Clarion, Nicollet, and Webster soils. Not the prettiest rating, but it sold.

Per cropland CSR2 point, that works out to about $163, which is right in line with the 88 CSR2 Clay County tracts at $145 to $156 per point. Lower-rated ground did not sell at a discount per point. It sold at a lower total because there are fewer points to pay for. If you own mid-70s ground, do not assume the market writes it off.

It also sold online-only, a format that suits a small tract where a full live sale may not draw enough bidders. Forty acres is not a lot of ground.

How should you use these results to price your farm?

Use them as a starting point, then adjust. Here is the order we work in when we build a free farm evaluation:

  1. Convert every comparable sale to price per cropland acre and per CSR2 point. Our post on what a CSR2 point is worth explains why.
  2. Match cropland share. A farm that is 70% tillable cannot be priced off one that is 95%.
  3. Check yield history and drainage. FSA program yields and tile maps catch what the soil map misses. This is likely where the Peterson gap came from.
  4. Read the terms. Four of these five sales advertised an open lease for 2027, which keeps operators in the bidding. A farm sold subject to a lease draws a different crowd.
  5. Weigh location and layout last, but do not skip them. In Sioux County, they outweighed a CSR2 gap of nearly seven points.

Deciding whether to sell at all this winter? Start with the best time to sell farmland in Iowa. If your farm has very different ground on different ends, how you split it matters as much as any of this. See how many tracts your farm should sell in, and for the wider market picture, our fall 2026 northwest Iowa farmland values update.

These are our sales, not someone else’s numbers off a database. We marketed every farm in that table and ran every sale. That is the comp set behind every evaluation we do in Clay, Cherokee, Palo Alto, Buena Vista, and the counties around them. If you want to know where your farm fits in this table, we will tell you straight, including when the honest answer is lower than your neighbor’s sale.

FAQ

What is northwest Iowa farmland selling for per CSR2 point right now?

In our fall 2026 sales, most tillable farms in Clay, Cherokee, and Palo Alto counties ran about $145 to $195 per CSR2 point on a cropland basis. Sioux County was a different animal, roughly $250 to $300. Location and farm quality push individual sales outside those ranges.

Why do auction results quote price per acre if some acres cannot be farmed?

Because land sells by the deeded or surveyed acre, and that is how the bid is called. It is accurate, but it bundles grass, timber, CRP, and building sites in with the cropland. Always check the cropland acres on the sale bill before comparing.

Are these final sale prices?

They are the winning bids on sales posted as sold. Each was subject to seller approval, and the November sales are set to close by mid-December. Until the deed transfers, the number is the bid, not the closing.

Where can I see new results as they happen?

Results go up on our previously sold page after each sale. To get them by email, along with upcoming auctions and listings, sign up for land notifications.

Thinking about what your farm would bring at auction this winter? Get a free farm evaluation built on these results and the rest of our local sales record.